Like everyone else on the OSGeo Discussion list I recently learnt far more than is good for me about cell based addressing systems when a long and loud discussion broke out over the merits of various systems.
Anyway one of the issues was whether when reporting an accident you would prefer to use MGRS or What3Words to locate yourself if you were away from your address, or you don’t have an address. Steve Swazee argued for MGRS while most of the rest of us thought W3W might have the edge. The following quote was used:
“Somehow I do not see a dispatcher saying to a responding officer, “Shots fired at 103132” :-)” Carl, you are wrong.
So I thought that I could do some experimenting, first I signed up for a What3Words API key (which was nice and easy). Then I went looking for some code to handle MGRS (not so easy it turns out) but I found some which fixed up some issues with the NASA WorldWind code (like needing all of WorldWind imported).
Sadly the W3W guys don’t have a Java developer yet (though I’m available) so there is no Java library (yet?) but it turns out not to be that hard to write one. My first attempt is here.
Then I ran the experiment:
start at 37.10, -112.12 to mgrs 12SVG 00476 06553 which becomes sparks.videotaped.televise and comes back to 37.100003, -112.120011 then start at 4QFJ12345678 goes to POINT (21.309433233733703 -157.91686743821978) which is unkind.riser.swimwear and back to POINT (21.309441 -157.916855)
And you know what in an emergency I think I’m going with
4QFJ12345678 any day. But with code to convert between the two we can let the best system win.